The independent resource for information and insights on the quality and integrity of lubricants in the marketplace.

Florida Deserves Better – Part II

November 9, 2015  

The Petroleum Quality Institute of America (PQIA) recently reported that the majority of motor oils PQIA observed on the shelves at convenience stores it recently visited in Florida are labeled as meeting only obsolete American Petroleum Institute (API) SA, SB, SC, and SG Service Categories.  These Categories apply to motor oils formulated for use in cars built prior to 1930, 1951, 1967, and 1993, respectively, and according to the API they are obsolete and not suitable for engines built after these model years.  Some, in fact, may cause harm to modern engines. To that, PQIA added that Florida deserves better.

Figure 1 Florida Deserves Better PT 2

Figure 1 — Obsolete Motor Oils PQIA Observed on the Shelves in Florida

So here they are, although PQIA suspects there could be more, the following are the obsolete brands observed on the shelves at the convenient stores PQIA recently visited in Florida. They include; XCEL PREMIUM, EASYLUBE Premium, 3X Super Premium, VTech, and Thunder motor oils. (See Figure 1)

Make no mistake about it, these obsolete motor oils are not hard to find. They are not dead stock covered with dust, hidden in a back room on top of a cooler in a Chokoloskee, Florida bait shop. Instead, (as shown in Figure 2) they are eye level products served up to consumers at many high traffic convenience stores PQIA visited in Miami, Opa-Locka, Dania, West Palm Beach and other areas in Florida. And with shelves loaded with these obsolete motor oils, there is little wonder why a consumer would think it’s all good.

Figure 2 Florida Deserves Better PT 2.gif

Figure 2 — What Consumers can see on Convenience Store Shelves in Florida

But truth be told, these motor oils are not good for nearly all cars currently on the road. In fact, some can cause damage.

With that in mind, how do you think consumers would react if the motor oils on store shelves were required by law to be identified under a prominently displayed sign at the top of the shelf that corresponded to the vehicle model years the products were meant to service? (See Example in Figure 3) Do you think many would reach for, and buy motor oils under the section labeled “Not suitable for use in gasoline-powered engines built after 1930. Use in more modern engines may cause unsatisfactory performance or equipment harm?” You can be sure very few, if any would.

Figure 3 Florida Deserves Better PT 2.gif

Figure 3 — What Consumers Should Understand about Some of the Motor Oils on the Shelves in Florida

But this is unfortunately not the case. No such identification or delineation of motor oils is required by law in the State of Florida to protect consumers from products that are obsolete and can cause equipment harm. As a result, obsolete motor oils are often the only products on the shelves, or sit side-by-side with motor oils that meet current specifications at many of the convenience stores PQIA visited in Florida. Further, the prices of these products are often just under motor oils meeting current specifications.

Because of this, the labels on obsolete motor oils can be extraordinarily deceiving, especially when these products are labeled as multigrade API SA/SB.  As noted in the previous article PQIA published about the motor oils in Florida, by definition, API SA motor oil cannot be a multi-viscosity grade product.

Consumers beware. Beware of obsolete motor oils on the shelves at convenience stores in Florida that are adorned with enticing labels, language, and viscosity grades suggestive of state-of-the-art technology. These oils are anything but. In fact, some of them can cause harm to your engine.

Related stories

Florida Deserves Better – Part I

4 Responses

  1. i am glad you do what you do. i have watched oil quality for the last 54 years. i search and learn about oil from you and api and amsoil. i read labels and do not put that filthy crap oil in my cars. not even old worn out beaters. thanks to you they have a hard time putting crap oil in good labeled bottles. i have been concerned about that all the years i have been driving and taking care of my cars.

    Like

    • most consumers have no idea what the differnce between SA and SN is. the bigger problem this oil is sold in bulk into quick lubes, dealerships and independent shops. and are telling consumers that they are getting a major brand oil

      Like

  2. store to store, city to city, state to state. same problem. i have been into many stores making a purchase. when i mention to the owners about their products, you get the same answer- SO

    Like

Trackbacks

  1. Test Results on Four Obsolete Motor Oil From Florida – PQIAblog
%d bloggers like this: